How Mental Shortcuts Affect Decision-Making

Nov 15, 2024 | Ebru Yildirim
Illustration showing how mental shortcuts affect decision-making, comparing everyday decisions with fast, unconscious, and automatic processes to complex decisions that require slow, conscious, and effortful thinking. Featured on Unlocked Potentials.

Have you ever made a quick decision just to question whether it was the correct one? We all do. These decisions frequently occur because our brains rely on mental shortcuts. They help us absorb information and make better decisions. While these can be helpful, they also come with risks.

Mental shortcuts play a big role in decision-making. They influence how we assess options, judge situations, and ultimately decide on a course of action. These shortcuts can be useful when time is limited or the decision isn’t very complex.

What Are Mental Shortcuts?

Mental shortcuts are the quick, automatic ways our brains make decisions based on their knowledge. They help us see what's important right now through all the noise. We don't look at everything; instead, we use patterns, past events, or simple rules of thumb to help us decide what to do.

The Different Types of Mental Shortcuts

There are some differences between them, but they all do the same thing: They help us make quick decisions when we're processing a lot of data, lacking time, or in the middle of a crisis. 

Availability Heuristic

Availability heuristic is a mental shortcut that relies on how easily something comes to mind.

Representativeness Heuristic

Representativeness heuristic is a mental shortcut in which we judge a situation or person based on how similar it is to something we already know. 

Anchoring Bias

Anchoring Bias is a mental shortcut that involves clinging to the first piece of information we come across—often without realising it.

The Pros and Cons of Using Mental Shortcuts

Mental shortcuts have advantages and disadvantages; understanding both sides can help us use them more effectively.

Advantages

  • Speed

    They allow us to make decisions quickly, especially when time is limited.

  • Efficiency

    Shortcuts help us conserve energy for other tasks or decisions by reducing the mental effort needed to process information.

Disadvantages

  • Inaccuracy

    They might cause us to make systematic errors or jump to conclusions that don’t reflect reality.

  • Over-simplification

    While shortcuts save time, they can often miss important details or the complexities of a situation, resulting in less well-rounded decisions.

Recognising these advantages and disadvantages helps us decide when to rely on mental shortcuts and when to evaluate a problem thoroughly. A life coach can assist in this process by helping us identify patterns, reflect on our choices, and weigh the pros and cons, ensuring we strike the right balance for better decision-making.

How Mental Shortcuts Influence Good vs. Bad Decision-Making

Visual representation of decision-making with mental shortcuts, depicting the choice between right and wrong paths. Highlights how mental shortcuts influence good vs. bad decision-making, as explored by Unlocked Potentials.

Depending on how we apply mental shortcuts, we can either make good or bad decisions. These heuristics can, on the one hand, save time and enable us to make fast, sensible decisions. However, mental shortcuts may also cause us to ignore important information or depend on limited or biased knowledge, leading to decisions that do not turn out as well as we’d hoped. 

Being aware is important for using mental tools well. Once we know how they work, we can step back and see if they're helping or holding us back. Balancing speed and thought with practice becomes easier, which helps us make more fruitful decisions.

Tips for Improving Decision-Making Skills

Being more mindful about how you make choices is the first step to getting better at making decisions. It's a balance between moving fast and giving things some thought. These tips should help:

  • Take a step back and look at what's going on.
  • Before you decide, make sure you know the most important facts.
  • Check if you rely too much on past events, biases, or stereotypes.
  • Think about possible scenarios or consequences of your choice.
  • Evaluate the choices you've made in the past, the good and the bad.

It takes time to improve your decision-making skills. Being aware of the process makes it easier to make sound and good decisions.

Balancing Efficiency with Rationality

Every day, we’re presented with a series of choices, and mental shortcuts are a natural part of our decision-making process. To make quick decisions and ensure favourable outcomes, we must learn to apply mental shortcuts strategically and consciously, knowing when they are beneficial and when they may lead us to the wrong path. We can make better decisions if we are aware of our thought patterns and intentional about our choices.

Finding the perfect balance between quick thought and careful consideration is not always simple, but it is an ability worth developing. With patience and knowledge, we may make decisions that feel right in the moment and benefit us in the long run.